Specimen

Tweet

Dating back to Rockland County No Vaudeville performed at The Cherry Lane Theatre in 1996, Randall Sharp’s work at Axis Theatre Company, later housed and performing still to this day beneath One Sheridan Square in the same spiritually charged basement that once sheltered Charles Ludlam’s Ridiculous Theatrical Company for thirty years, has always trafficked in a kind of ecstatic disrepair. Her latest production, Specimen, arrives like a transmission from a dying satellite: garbled, abrasive, funny, ugly, unexpectedly moving, and very much alive.

The audience enters to find the bridge of the spaceship Nomad, a vessel so battered and exhausted that it appears to be held together by memory, rust, and resentment. Computer monitors flicker with corrupted video loops while a stream of exposition leaks from malfunctioning terminals. A corporation called VitaNavis has sent ships to the “four corners of the known universe” in search of alien lifeforms; payment depends on the quantity and quality of living specimens returned. It is one of Sharp’s sharpest jokes that capitalism has survived interstellar travel entirely intact. Humanity may have conquered the cosmos, but it is still working on commission.

The mission, naturally, has gone catastrophically wrong. Most of the crew has either fled, died, or mentally dissolved. The specimens have expired through negligence or incompetence, leaving behind little more than foul odors and scattered jars. The crew subsists on a dubious ration called SUP—Standard Universal Pamarack—a contaminated sludge that appears to induce paranoia, cognitive collapse, and fatal hemorrhaging. Yet no one aboard the Nomad seems especially troubled by this fact. In Sharp’s universe, institutional decay is so normalized that even madness becomes routine maintenance.

What follows is 70 minutes of sustained theatrical turbulence. Characters scream across the stage as though volume itself might restore order to the cosmos. Dr. Gardener, played with twitching exasperation by Andrew Dawson, and the nominally authoritative Lieutenant Gordon, embodied by Julian Rozzell Jr., spend much of the evening prodding a dying organism that resembles the aftermath of a particularly traumatic taxidermy experiment. The grotesque creature, designed by scenic and props co-designer Lynn Mancinelli, is one of the production’s most inspired visual jokes: a mangled extraterrestrial housecat whose pathetic mortality becomes oddly heartbreaking.

Sharp directs the ensemble like a conductor overseeing an orchestra determined to play different symphonies simultaneously. Yet the resulting cacophony possesses its own strange rigor. Jim Sterling’s Louden, the communications officer and self-appointed musical curator, pedals a bicycle through the ship while accidentally sabotaging every machine he touches. The soundscape by Paul Carbonara fills the production with bursts of downtown punk absurdity. Static eruptions, musical fragments, and failed transmissions ricochet through the theater like the final broadcasts from civilization’s nervous breakdown.

Among the crew, the most emotionally coherent presence belongs to engineer Overholser, played by Britt Genelin with bruised stoicism and mounting dread. Recovering from an attack by another crewmember, she insists repeatedly that she is “fine,” a declaration that becomes increasingly existential. Elsewhere, Jon McCormick’s medical assistant Longshore drifts through the chaos with unhelpful detachment, while Mancinelli’s captain appears only through video monitors, deteriorating into authoritarian hysteria from a safe digital distance. Everyone aboard the Nomad seems trapped inside the same collapsing nervous system.

The play pivots magnificently upon the arrival of a visitor, portrayed by Brian Barnhart with bewildered elegance. Ejected from a neighboring vessel in a small escape pod, he may be an “Andro-Primatus,” a shape-shifting alien capable of mimicking humanity and worth an enormous bounty. Or he may simply be another victim of contaminated SUP suffering catastrophic neurological damage. Sharp wisely refuses certainty. Barnhart’s performance hovers between alien innocence and psychotic fracture, particularly when he stares at his own body in horror and mutters, “Something’s banging in my chest. I’m standing on two things touching the ground.” It is one of the evening’s funniest lines and also one of its most chilling. Human embodiment itself suddenly appears grotesque and implausible.

Visually, Specimen resembles the fever dream of a junk dealer raised on 1970s science fiction. We anxiously anticipate the arrival of Robot B-9 from Lost in Space shouting “Danger, Will Robinson!,” but that level of comfort zone never materializes…wink, wink. The set, designed collaboratively by Sharp, McCormick, and Mancinelli, is a glorious landfill of keyboards, monitors, knobs, exposed wiring, and industrial debris. It evokes a radical version of the control room from any low budget sci-fi film of the 70s, as though salvaged after decades drifting through radioactive space. David Zeffren’s lighting bathes the production in bruised blues and flashing emergency reds, transforming the basement theater into a claustrophobic purgatory of technological exhaustion. The entire environment feels one electrical surge away from extinction.

For much of the evening, Sharp withholds explicit political commentary, allowing the production’s chaos to function allegorically rather than polemically. Then, suddenly, she lands a devastating blow. Subjected to abusive testing, the suspected alien finally asks his captors, “What kind of people are you?” Gordon answers proudly: “We’re Americans.” The line detonates inside the theater. Everything Sharp has been building—the corporate greed, the commodification of bodies, the paranoia toward outsiders, the collapse of empathy—snaps brutally into focus. The monsters in Specimen are not extraterrestrials. They are ordinary workers dutifully participating in systems they barely understand.

Yet Sharp’s ultimate concern may be less political than existential. Specimen asks what it means to exist under constant observation. The captured aliens are specimens, certainly, but so are the crew members trapped by VitaNavis, monitored by corporate authority, poisoned by their environment, and reduced to economic function. Even the actors seem implicated, pinned beneath the audience’s gaze like insects beneath glass. The production becomes, finally, a meditation on captivity itself: social captivity, economic captivity, psychological captivity, theatrical captivity.

The miracle of Specimen is that its disorder is so meticulously composed. The set is chaos. The narrative is chaos too. The characters hurtle in competing directions like particles in a broken accelerator. But Sharp understands that contemporary life itself increasingly feels assembled from malfunction, noise, contamination, and collapsing systems barely held together by habit. Watching the production is like staring into a box of frantic carpenter ants as they dismantle a croissant, each movement chaotic yet mysteriously purposeful. What emerges is not coherence but recognition. Specimen may masquerade as a ramshackle sci-fi farce, but beneath its glorious clutter lies a bleakly lucid portrait of a culture drifting through space with poisoned food, broken machinery, and no clear memory of how to get home.

Specimen (through June 6, 2026)

Axis Theatre Company

Axis Theatre, 1 Sheridan Square, in Manhattan

For tickets, visit www.axiscompany.org

Running time: 70 minutes without an intermission