They’ll have Pip and “the gentlemen” over for dinner one night; but coming up with an available date proves difficult: Paul, an architect, has a talk on “post-colonial Dutch architecture” one proposed night, and his daughter’s “nutcracker recital” on another–not to mention his son’s “first violin recital” on yet another. (Ruhl wastes no time in establishing the cultural credentials of her two, middle-aged, married couples.) The first night that seems feasible for the four of them is New Year’s Eve. Welcome to Scene Two of Ruhl’s play, when Pip shows up with David (pronounced “Da-veed”) and Freddie, her two live-in partners, for dinner and for what becomes the play’s longest and most pivotal scene including a sex orgy involving the seven of them.
The orgy begins after Pip sings “She’ll be Coming ‘Round the Mountain” (“…when she comes”), karaoke-style, while giving new meaning to the refrain, “She’ll be riding six white horses….,” as she comes on to each of the other six characters in the living room, handsomely designed by David Zinn. Rebecca Taichman’s direction becomes a work of art, as the seven actors proceed to move as one, like a living and breathing sculpture.
In Act II, however, we’re made to question just exactly what it was that we saw, or didn’t see, as the case may be. The fact that Pip and her partners showed up with hash brownies which they all consume gives Ruhl a lot of leeway for stretching her story into some uncharted and unknowable territory. Was George, perhaps, hallucinating some of what occurred, and what we believed to be the case? There is also at least one development, in the second act, which is either supernatural and metaphysical or outrageous, depending on your point of view.
Following the intermission, George is to be found hunting deer in the wilds of New Jersey with Pip; but it’s George who, in the end, undergoes a spiritual transcendence, having little or nothing to do, really, with the dog she accidentally slays with a bow and arrow, when she thought she was shooting a dear. In the meantime, Jane and Michael’s daughter, Jenna (Naian Gonzalez Norvind) walked in on her parents’ sex orgy, at the end of the first act, only to run away and hide by the beginning of the second.
While How to Transcend a Happy Marriage emerges as one of the most thought-provoking plays of the year, as well as one of Ruhl’s best, the built-in irony of the title takes on a special meaning when we learn, in the end, that it really is about transcendence, through “harmony.” In fact, How to Transcend… may feel overly contrived, since David is a mathematician, who specializes in Pythagorian geometry and triangles, and Michael is a musician, who tells us about “triads” and also that “three is the number of harmony.” Ruhl’s play begins, more or less, with the three-way relationship between Pip and her compatriots, and it ends with George’s finding “harmony,” in at least three different ways. Add to this that each of the four main characters has “three best friends,” and Ruhl–who is perhaps best known for In the Next Room or the Vibrator Play–is providing a recipe for a harmonious play.
Marisa Tomei excels as George, the narrator of How to Transcend…–and of her own story. Thanks to Tomei’s vocal and visual expressions, we constantly share in George’s ongoing surprise, as she graduates from naivety to knowledge. In the end, it is George who has the most “transcendent,” and religious, experience. (It is not insignificant that we’re told George is the only Catholic in the group.) “It seems like you have omniscience,” says George, in her closing monologue, “when you can talk to the audience in a play.” And talk to us, she does, in the playwright’s smart, yet snappy language. Consider George also telling us that Jenna, “over time forgave us,” after walking in on her parent’s participating in a sex orgy. And “the trauma of seeing her parents’ aberrant sex lives up close–it became an anecdote in a college application.” Or consider David’s saying: “I’m from everywhere. And nowhere. I moved constantly as a child…. as a result, I don’t really believe in nationality.”
With her black lipstick and aqua-tinged, long hair, Lena Hall presents an extremely out-there Pip, who really is a “pip” of a character, no less than “a beautiful woman in her late twenties, named Deborah.” (Pip also, “according to the American legal system,” goes by the name of Diana, which is, of course, the name in Roman mythology of the goddess of the hunt.) Omar Metwally offers a sturdy Paul, Brian Hutchison a reliable Michael, and Robin Weigert is fine as Jane. David McElwee is an appropriately bohemian David, in Susan Hilferty’s appropriately loose-fitting coats and big boots, and David McElwee is the somewhat effete Freddie.
How to Transcend a Happy Marriage (through May 7, 2017)
Lincoln Center Theater
Mitzi E. Newhouse Theater, 150 West 65th Street, in Manhattan
For tickets, call 212-239-6200 or visit http://www.ltx.insiteticketing.com
Running time: two hours including one intermission